One of the coolest phenomenons in audio right now is the big improvements moving forward in the budget sector. $100 headphones can and do compete with $400 headphones, and $25 headphones sometimes compete with $200 headphones. It’s a great time to be an audiophile, even if your budget isn’t as large as you’d like it to be. In this series we’ll see how much you get from stepping up from a budget under $25 to a budget under $50. In order to have some comparison with the under $25 segment of the market, I’ll be including the top 2 IEMs from the $25 IEM Shootout, once they are determined.
In this $50 IEM shootout series I’ll post a new set of impressions every Friday until I’ve done them all. Then I’ll select my top 3 from the list. After I’ve selected my top 3, I’ll do a post ranking the remaining units and giving them our trademark visual ratings. Finally, a post will compare the top 3 IEMs under $50 that I have in my possession. If any manufacturers want to send additional under $50 units that they think might rank before I’ve done my ranking posts, I’ll add them in. I’m hopeful that I’ll be able to get the Final Audio e2000 into this contest, too, as I’ve heard good things.
Here are our contestants:
- Lypertek Mevi ($29.90, Penon Audio)
- TFZ Series 2 ($45.00, Penon Audio)
- BGVP SGZ-DN1 ($29.00, Penon Audio)
- Dawnwood GT-36 Halo ($49.90, Penon Audio)
- xDuoo EP1 ($29.90, Penon Audio)
- Tin Audio T2 ($49.90, Penon Audio)
- RHA S500i ($33.99, amazon.com)
- Magaosi BK50 ($45.50, Penon Audio)
- Alpha & Delta D3 ($35, amazon.com)
- TRN V80 ($43.99, amazon.com)
- BQEYZ KB100 ($49.90, Penon Audio)
- Linsoul BLD ($39.99 – $45.99, amazon.com)
- $25 IEM Shootout #1
- $25 IEM Shootout #2
The TFZ Series 2 was provided by Penon Audio. I do not have to return the IEM. I have not been compensated. The opinions presented are my own.
Unboxing / Functionality
The box is long. It’s so long that I couldn’t fit it in a reasonably sized image. It has some interesting elements. What the heck is ambilight (this, apparently)? What is the name of the company even talking about? The Fragrant Zither (TFZ), leaves me clueless, clutching at straws. Does the name mean MADNESS!?
A damsel with a dulcimerIn a vision once I saw:It was an Abyssinian maidAnd on her dulcimer she played,Singing of Mount Abora.Could I revive within meHer symphony and song,To such a deep delight ’twould win me,That with music loud and long,I would build that dome in air,That sunny dome! those caves of ice!And all who heard should see them there,And all should cry, Beware! Beware!His flashing eyes, his floating hair!Weave a circle round him thrice,And close your eyes with holy dreadFor he on honey-dew hath fed,And drunk the milk of Paradise.—Excerpt from Kubla Khan, by Samuel Taylor Coleridge. Inspired by an opium dream.
The TFZ fit fine in my ear and the cable is comfortable. The included tips work fine. Good to go!
I thought I was good to go. When I went to do my full on sound impressions I lost sound in my left earpiece. I switched to a different inexpensive 2-pin cable, the one that comes with the Shozy-AAW Hibiki Mk.2. It’s an inexpensive and good cable from an IEM in roughly the same price range (about $60). I think the cable is actually an improvement sonically, more body. It’s unfortunate that the cable that came with the Series 2 was not terribly well made, it will definitely affect the rankings.
As usual, I’ve not burned these in. I have listened to them for about 15-20 hours. These are dynamic driver in-ears, so sound very well could still change. I’m prepared to change what I think about them later. I’m still holding the position that most folks won’t actually go through burning in their headphones in an objective way. They’ll listen to them, which will give brain burn-in as well as mechanical burn in and it will be nearly impossible to tell the difference. If you want to actually tell the difference, take some observations of initial sound with reference tracks, throw them in a drawer with your burn-in routine, and then bring them back out for the same tracks. There’s still flaws in the method:
- ideally you’d have two headphones with no measurable differences at baseline, with one burned in and the other not before any listening was done
- they then would be played with minimal switching time at the same volume on the same tracks
- listening would be blinded to which headphone was used
Since I’m not buying two of any of these, and neither are most consumers, observations about burn in are anecdotal at best, so if you want to do it, at least control some things, like your own perception of the IEMs. Don’t give yourself enough time to get used to them.
The sources for listening were the HiBy R3 and LG V30. I think most folks would be listening out of affordable players or their phone. The LG V30 is widely regarded as one of the best, if not the best, sounding phone. The HiBy R3 has a touch-screen, Bluetooth & WiFi, Tidal, a good form factor and great sound at a very good price ($239). As noted above, I had to switch cables due to what was likely a soldering fault on the 3.5mm jack, so these impressions aren’t pure.
- Beck – Salt In The Wound is vivacious with groovy bass, some nice maraca percussion and pointy guitars.
- There is a nice delicate breathiness to Amber Rubarth – Washing Day in the vocal department with a touch of inviting warmth, but the bass is a touch soft and slightly recessed.
- On Amber Rubarth – Tundra the stage gets very slightly outside the ears and depth is okay. The Series 2 doesn’t have a huge soundstage but it is very respectable at this price level.
- The speed and precision of Animals as Leaders – Lippincott is handled fairly well with only a little bit of blending in really complex portions partly due to slightly shallower depth than the stage in the track. Good performance for under $50.
- The guiro on Blue Oyster Cult – (Don’t Fear) The Reaper is a touch recessed, along with the rest of the vocal. Guitars are less energetic than the track normally puts out. The differences are only slight, but enough for me to notice. The sound is slightly easy going, a bit less vigourous than expected. This will appeal to some, and not others.
- The bass on The Shins – Sleeping Lessons is a bit forward and midbass centric with a bit of emphasis and longer lingering. The lower octaves of the bass notes don’t show up in full. The treble doesn’t reach the extension of the track, easy going, as said before. The resolution on the cymbal crashes after about 2:30 is good, not splashy, not tinny, nicely done.
- Mambo Sun by T. Rex is a simple track, with an easy grooving energy. The energy is a bit more easy going on the Series 2. Tone edges are softer and smoother. Guitars less crunchy.
- The overall tone of the Series 2 is relaxed with slightly recessed mids, slightly raised and midbass with expanded decay, and a little bit of energy taken off the upper treble. This makes the Series 2 an easy listen for just melting into the music on your daily grind. These aren’t stand up and take notice v-shape in-ears and they aren’t neutral reference either. These are warm, soft and tuneful. They are nice.